Imprimatur
← The great ideas

Government

Key terms
Why government
Its forms
Its structure
Its limits

Necessity

Why do people need government at all? Necessity here means the need of a people for something to rule it. These readings ask whether it comes from human nature, from conflict, or from human faults.

4 readings

In Book I of the Politics, Aristotle, having traced the household and the village to the city, concludes that “a city is a natural production, and that man is naturally a political animal”. He adds that one “naturally and not accidentally unfit for society” must be “inferior or superior to man”, citing Homer’s “without society, without law, without family”. The passage sits under this term as the classical ground of the political community.

In the first chapter of Book I of Saint Thomas Aquinas’s On Kingship (De Regno), a short treatise addressed to a king of Cyprus, he argues from the natural “society of many” to the need of “an agency to take care of what appertains to the commonweal”. He cites the body’s “general ruling force” and the text of Solomon, “Where there is no governor, the people shall fall” (Prov 11:14). The passage sits under this term as the doctor’s version of Aristotle’s argument.

In Part II, chapter 17 of Leviathan, “Of the Causes, Generation, and Definition of a Common-wealth”, Hobbes names “the finall Cause, End, or Designe of men” in submitting to the restraint of commonwealths: “the foresight of their own preservation”, to be rid of “that miserable condition of Warre” when no “visible Power” keeps them “in awe”. The passage sits under this term as the account of the sovereign’s purpose.

The first section of Paine’s Common Sense (1776), “Of the Origin and Design of Government in General”, begins by separating “society” from “government”: the first “produced by our wants”, the second “by our wickedness”. He calls government “a necessary evil”. The pamphlet was written to urge American independence. The passage sits under this term as a statement of government’s origin and design.