Imprimatur
← The great ideas

Law

Key terms
What law is
Its kinds
Applying it
Law and the state

Reason and command

Is law a matter of reason or of will? Law is a rule of conduct laid on those who can obey it or not, and it is often defined either as a rule of reason or as a command. These readings ask what makes a rule a law, and who has the right to make one.

3 readings

In the Summa Theologica, First Part of the Second Part, question 90, article 1, Aquinas asks “whether law is something pertaining to reason”. In the body of the article he gives “a rule and measure of acts”, derives “lex” from “ligare”, and refers it to reason as the first principle of human acts. The question opens the Treatise on Law, and the article stands under this term as its first step.

Question 90, article 4 of the First Part of the Second Part of the Summa Theologica asks whether promulgation is essential to law, and closes the question with the definition gathered “from the four preceding articles”. The replies cite Isidore’s derivation of “lex” from “legere”. The Treatise on Law is the most cited part of Aquinas on this matter. The passage sits under this term as the definition itself.

Part II, chapter 26 of Hobbes’s Leviathan (1651), “Of Civill Lawes”, begins with the distinction of “Counsell” from “Command” and defines the civil law as the command of the “Persona Civitatis”. The chapter follows his chapters on the commonwealth and its sovereign. It sits under this term for law as command.