Imprimatur
← The great ideas

Quantity

Key terms
Its nature
Magnitude
Number
Size and measure

Quantity and substance

Is quantity something in addition to a thing, or only the thing seen as having parts? Quantity is what a thing has in being divisible into parts and so greater or less than another. These readings ask how quantity relates to the substance that has it.

5 readings

In Book V, chapter 13 of the Metaphysics, Aristotle defines “quantum” as that which is divisible into constituent parts, a “plurality” if it is numerable and a “magnitude” if measurable. He then distinguishes length, breadth and depth. Book V is a lexicon of philosophical terms, and the passage sits under quantity and substance as the definition from which later scholastic usage proceeds.

In the Summa Theologica, Third Part, question 76, article 3, Aquinas asks whether Christ is in the sacrament “whole under every part” of the species. He answers that the “whole nature of a substance” lies under every part of the “dimensions” that contain it. The article belongs to the doctrine of the Eucharist, and it sits under quantity and substance for its use of the terms.

In Part II, section 8 of the Principles of Philosophy (1644), Descartes says that “quantity differs from extended substance” and “number from what is numbered” only “in our thought”, and not in reality. The Second Part sets out the principles of material things. The passage sits under quantity and substance as the Cartesian reduction of the term.

In Part IV, chapter 46 of Leviathan (1651), Hobbes criticises the scholastic account of “Condensed” and “Rarefied” bodies and says that quantity is “nothing else but the determination of Matter”. The chapter is a polemic against the schools. The passage sits under quantity and substance as the materialist’s answer to the scholastic usage.

In the Scholium to Proposition 15 of Part I of the Ethics (1677), Spinoza answers an objection about quantity by saying it is conceived in two ways: “in the abstract”, as imagined, and “as substance”, as conceived by the intellect. The work is set out in geometrical order. The passage sits under quantity and substance as his statement of the distinction.