Imprimatur
← The great ideas

Revolution

Key terms
What it is
Why it comes
Change of order
The question of right

Sedition and rebellion

When does discontent become a crime against the community? Sedition is stirring up or preparing a rising against lawful authority, and rebellion is the open act of opposing that authority by force. These readings ask what exactly is being opposed, a person or the order of law, and how seriously the wrong should be judged.

2 readings

Question 42, article 1 of the Second Part of the Second Part of the Summa Theologica asks “whether sedition is a special sin”, and Aquinas answers it in the body of the article. The Summa is the standard summa of scholastic theology, and he sets “sedition” beside “war” and “strife”, the vices opposed to peace. It stands under this term as the definition of the word.

In chapter XIX of Locke’s Second Treatise of Government, “Of the Dissolution of Government”, he takes up the charge that his doctrine invites “rebellion”. The treatise was written to defend the settlement of 1688 and became a principal source of liberal constitutional thought. The passage sits here as his own account of what “rebellion” is.