Imprimatur
← The great ideas

Slavery

Key terms
The grounds of slavery
The institution
Freedom claimed
Other bondage

Natural slavery

Are some people slaves by nature? Natural slavery is the claim that certain persons are by their make-up fitted to be ruled and owned. These readings ask who held this view, how it was qualified, and why it was later rejected.

3 readings

Book I, chapter 5 of Aristotle’s Politics belongs to the discussion of the household and of its parts, master and slave among them. He speaks of men who are “slaves by nature” and of the relation of “body” to “soul”. The Politics was the chief source for the scholastic treatment of the question, and Aquinas cites it. The passage stands under this term as the opinion of the Philosopher, set out in his own words.

The Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, question 57, article 3, asks “Whether the right of nations is the same as the natural right”, within the treatise on justice. Aquinas distinguishes what is “absolutely” of natural right from what follows from “some resultant utility”, and takes slavery as his example, with the Politics cited. The passage stands under this term as the scholastic treatment of the matter.

In Plurimis is an encyclical letter of Leo XIII of 1888 to the bishops of Brazil, written on the occasion of the abolition of slavery in that country. In section 5 the pope recalls the opinion of “the wisest in the pagan world” and goes on to the teaching of the Church. The letter is a papal statement on the history of the institution, and it stands under this term for that reason.